Sunday, September 8, 2013

The Best Train Apps for Young Kids

For some reason, although trains are not especially prevalent in many parts of the US, they are an intensely popular subject of attention for kids. In Atlanta where we live, aside from amusement parks and shopping malls, the kids don't get much exposure to real trains. We once took the kids to the Southern Railway Museum, where you can ride in an actual passenger coach. We got in, rode 100 feet backward, then 100 forward to where we started. Incredible! In spite of it all, characters like Thomas & Friends and Chuggington, as well a multitude of train-themed toys, hold our toddlers' attention endlessly. 

As of late, my husband Shawn has been building the kids a train track each morning using our ever-growing collection of wooden tracks. Son1 and I grade the track each day. Son1 always grades it 100%, but I'm much more discerning. It's usually around 90-95%. Here's a particularly good one I rewarded a 97.

Aerial track view with Son1

So, the apps are the purpose of this blog... Son1, being 4, is most into the apps that allow him to "create" trains and drive them around the track. Son2, 20 months, likes to tap things (often I show him where to tap) and see animals or other animated surprises appear (that is when he's not doing his favorite iPad activity: pushing the Home button, causing us to leave the app entirely). 

There's not a category for "trains" in the app store, so I've scoured it best I could to find the winners. And there were lots that didn't make the cut. First, here's my list of top train apps (mildly in order starting with my personal favorite) for various interests and levels, ages 2-5. My research assistants (ages 4 and 1.5) are less discerning however, so I'll mention some of their favorites after mine. They like mine too, but have some less mommy-friendly additions. 

My criteria for choosing these are educational, easy to use, creative, nice graphics and sounds, keep attention for 10+ minutes, keep kids coming back


Lego Duplo Train
Hell yeah, a FREE kids' app that's worth a damn! That's why it's first in the list. First the kids build their Lego train, picking a few trains cars for their train. Then they drive around a track, stopping to do little activities like pick up freight, drop off Lego passengers, or fill up with gas. It took a little working together for Son1 to get the hang of the controls, but as parents, we really should be playing the apps with the kids rather than using technology as a babysitter, right? Or at least some mix of the both :) 

FREE for iPhone and iPad in the app store

Zoo Train
There's just something about animals+trains that gets the kids excited. This app has 5 mini-games revolving around trains: puzzles, music, spelling, train building, and track building. While I wouldn't say it's hours of fun, it's certainly minutes of fun. And those minutes add up after playing a few times. It's a visually pleasing quickie with quality sounds and is easy to use for even the little ones.

$1.99 for iPhone and iPad in the app store


Peek-a-Zoo Train 
Each car on the train has a different animal. Tap the car to see a cute animal animation and hear the name of the animal. Great graphics and easy to use for the littlest ones because they can tap anywhere on the screen to go forward.
Warning there are some frustrations in this app. My older one found it a little frustrating because there's no way to replay on of the animals and you can only move forward in the train, not go back to one of the animals he liked. Tip: the Menu button is hidden between one of clouds.

$2.99 for iPhone and iPad in the app store
Lite version also available, with limited number of trains

Freight Train 
I really wish they had an iPad version so we could experience the artwork from the original book by Donald Crews on a larger screen. This interactive book lets kids learn about the different train cars while playing train-themed music in the background (really nice harmonica style music with lovely vocals). Limited in functionality - it takes about as long to play as it would to read the book. Definitely worth a buck. 
$0.99 for iPhone only/no iPad version in the app store
Thomas & Friends Apps 
There are too many to list, but you can't go wrong with the Thomas apps. They tend to cost $2-5, so I couldn't possibly download them all. The ones we have tried have good visuals and are easy for kids to use on their own (except as previously noted, I always monitor them). Most of the apps are some combination of puzzles, matching, moving train supplies this way and that, coloring activities, and a story. They also have quite a few Thomas interactive book apps. There's even one iPad app (Steam Team) that goes with a play set you have to buy, and it tells the kids to do different physical activities. Sounds cool but the play set is like $30 so maybe we'll try it for a birthday gift? 

Our favorite of the Thomas apps is the Thomas Game Pack $2.99 for iPhone and iPad in the app store 

Working on the Railroad 
You get a lot for $2 with this one. There are several games - puzzles, build a train, learning shapes/letters to build the word "Train", a train scene to explore, and a sing-a-long (of course to "working on the railroad", and a pretty decent rendition at that). The graphics, animations, and game play are ok - nothing outstanding, but a solid app on the whole.

$1.99 for iPhone and iPad in the app store
Lite version also available, with limited content
Clicky Sticky 
This app is a good one for preschoolers. They pick the cars to go on their train, then drive it through the zoo (see what I mean - again with the animals+trains combo!) They can control the speed of the train, which is a actually a pointless control - what kid doesn't just want to crank it up as fast as it can go? Anyway, Son1 loves to make different configurations of trains and drive them full throttle. It took a little help from Mom and Dad to figure it out at first.

 $1.99 for iPhone and iPad in the app store

Animal Train
Free, with in-app purchase for full content (this is not my favorite model because you feel kind of gypped when you're excited to download a free app then find out you have to pay for anything cool). You get 2 trains to start with, then get the other 4 unlocked for something like $2.99 (I can't remember how much for certain, but I did shell it over).
Still, this app is simple and fun for the kids to explore. Each train car has different animals on it. Tap each one to see what they do. The music is nice. Definitely a good one for the under 3 crowd. My 4 year old likes it too, although it's not as challenging and creative as some of the apps geared more towards his age. 

 Free for iPhone and iPad in the app store, but in-app purchase to unlock all content


Build a Train Apps 
This suite of apps work together, but each one stands alone as well. 

Design a Train 
You can choose which cars you want and paint each one of them. Not too fancy, but you can import the designs into the other two apps.
$1.99 for iPhone and iPad in the app store, plus in-app purchases for additional trains
Lite version, with even less trains

Build a Train
Select the cars to put on your train, then pick a track to drive it (a few are free, a lot are for purchase). Son1 always wants to get in-app purchases like this, which can be maddening, but I've used it as an opportunity to teach him about saving and spending money. Rather than just buying him a track, he has to earn it by doing chores.
$2.99 with in app purchases for iPhone and iPad in the app store
Lite version, with even less tracks

Build a Train Puzzles 
Pretty standard puzzle app, but the cool part is you can import the trains you've created in the other 2 apps.
$1.99 for iPhone and iPad in the app storeplus in-app purchases 




KIDS' PICKS
Not my picks per se, but the kids love them so I can't complain. 

Whopping Trains 
Train videos. Enough said. The user interface is miserable, but for kids who like to watch videos of real trains, this is a goldmine. They have lots of 1-2 minute clips of trains going over bridges, through the woods, etc, etc. 
FREE for iPhone and iPad in the app store, with in-app purchase for more videos/less advertising

Let's Play With the Trains 
This one is actually pretty fun. Use your finger to draw a line on the screen, and a train will follow it like a track. Draw multiple lines and multiple trains appear. Son1 likes to draw lines with lots of curves and swirls, so the trains get kind of twisted up. But he's 4, so I try not to dwell long on these things and just let him have fun.
FREE for iPhone and iPad in the app store, with $4.99 in-app purchase to disable ads




NOTABLE MENTIONS
These ones aren't so bad either...

Toca Train
People seem to rave about this one because it's from Toca Boca, who admittedly do a lot of awesome apps. I don't quite get the draw outside of that because the 3D is kind of kludgy. But hey, go for it. 
$2.99 for iPhone and iPad in the app store

Railroad Train 
A puzzle game that's geared more towards older kids. My kids like to watch mommy and daddy play it. 
FREE for iPhone and iPad in the app store

ABC train
Again with the unstoppable animals+train combo, plus letters to boot. The graphics aren't great, but it's a decent way to learn letters. The ads are a big drawback though.
FREE for iPhone and iPad in the app store, with ads

Abby train 
As with all the Abby apps, the voices on this annoy me and the graphics are kind of cheesy, but the games and content are pretty educational and fun. Just for clarity, the full name for this one is actually Animal Train Preschool Adventure First Word Learning Games for Toddler Loves Farm and Zoo Animals by Monkey Abby. A little naming overkill perhaps?
$1.99 for iPhone and iPad in the app store



Leave me a comment if I missed a good one. There are others I purposefully didn't mentioned because they're no good :)


Wednesday, July 10, 2013

Must-Have Apps for Kids 2-4

Oh the hours I've tried to pry lame, annoying, user un-friendly apps from Son1's hands. He's 4 so he gets fixated on one aspect of an app and won't let go, no matter how frustrated we both get with it. Maybe it has a cute cartoon monster on the app icon, or suggests the promise of ramming monster trucks together, but you can't do anything without buying the "full version" (more on the full version quagmire in another post!), or plays obnoxious music you can't turn off, or hogs all your memory and crashes constantly. 

Anecdote Time: 
One of my least favorite apps (to remain unnamed because I can't bear to look it up) involves choosing a train from the main menu. There are 3 trains to choose from: one green, one red, and one orange. 

Pick the GREEN train and it takes you to a track where you drive a GREEN train. 
Pick the RED train and it takes you to a different track, where you drive a GREEN train. 
Pick the ORANGE train and it takes you to a different track, where you drive a GREEN train. You don't have to be 4 to wonder why all the trains are GREEN, right? 

Like I said, he's 4, so after picking the ORANGE train, a barrage of questions ensues. It starts with "Where is the orange train?"
He tries picking the orange train again. Still green. "How do I get the orange train?"
He tries again. "Why is the train green?"
Again. "Where is the orange train?" 
Again. "Mommy, can you get the orange train?"
Again. "Why is this train green?"  

No matter how I try to explain that the app just doesn't work right, and the train will always be green, all he wants is the damned orange train. More than anything. Only the orange train will do. Finally I say, "Oh no, the app is broken. Let's delete it." That should be the end of it, right? No, in the car a few days later, I hear "Mommy, can we get the orange train?" 

App Time
There are an incredible number of worthless, terrible apps in the world. There are a bunch of good ones. This blog post is about the few that are the very best. These are the MUST-HAVES*. If you have a 2-4 year old, not having these is simply unholy...


Endless ABC
This is probably my all-time favorite app, even more so than Facebook (blasphemy!)
It is an incredibly fun and intoxicatingly cute way to learn about letters and words. As you drag letters to spell out words, the letters wiggle and voice their sounds in funny ways. Once the word is complete, a whimsical animation explains the word's meaning. 

There is a pretty extensive list of words (2 or more for each letter) and new words are continually being added, so the kids get something new each time they play.

$4.99 for iPhone and iPad in the app store


Elmo Loves ABCs 
This app feels very much like a segment on Sesame Street if it was interactive. Elmo tells kids exactly what to do, and responds to their actions in a very realistic way. He tells the kids to pick a letter, walks them through the steps in drawing the letter, then rewards them with videos and activities about words that start with that letter.

$4.99 For iPad in the App Store  (no iPhone version)

They also have Elmo Loves 123s, which I haven't tried, but it's first on the list when my app budget is replenished. 


The Monster at the End of this Book 
If you don't remember this book from your childhood, you were deprived (I was one of the deprived). Grover narrates this interactive adaptation, begging kids not to turn the pages of the book. The first time we read it, Son1 actually refused to turn the pages, so as not to upset poor Grover. 


Equally good is Another Monster at the End of this Book, co-starring Elmo. 


Preschool Monkey Lunchbox
Best buck I ever spent. This one's for the younger crowd (2-3 I'd say), and boy it is a road trip lifesaver. Driving from New York to Atlanta? No problem. Flying coast-to-coast? Yes please.

The monkey guides kids through a series of different puzzles, matching, counting, shape/color/size/ differentiation games. Warning: the game never ends, so you may have to set a time limit.



Wheels on the Bus (and pretty much any app by Duck Duck Moose)
Duck Duck Moose has turned many nursery rhymes into fun musical journeys through lands where kids use different gestures to interact with the characters in the songs. Filled with surprises, these apps encourage kids to scrutinize the details of each scene to find their goodies.

$1.99 for iPad and iPhone in the App Store

We have particularly enjoyed Wheels on the Bus because the flow is pretty linear (one scene for each verse in the song), so we are all clear on when the app is "over". We've also enjoyed Old McDonald and Itsy Bitsy Spider. Duck Duck Moose has several others as well, perhaps for us to try after payday. 


Few truly good kids' apps are free. There are some, but none currently make my Must-Have list. Sorry if you're a cheapie. Believe me, I used to be a cheapie, but after so much app disappointment, I realized it's ok to pay a few bucks for an app (if it's a good one, of course). I'd easily spend $5 at Target on a new book for the kids, so why not spend it on a really good app?

Maybe there are other must-haves. What are they?


* "Must-haves" are high on the scale for each of these criteria: educational, easy to use, fun, keep attention for 10+ minutes, keep kids coming back